| NAME | TERM | |||
| Joseph Grover | 1856-1859 | |||
| Sheldon B. Cutler | 1860-1871 | |||
| John Burt | 1872-1876 | |||
| Chester C. Loveland | 1877-1894 | |||
| Richard E. Davis | 1895-1898 | |||
| H.H. Cordon | 1899-1902 | |||
| Joseph Josephson | 1903-1910 | |||
| Joseph R. Olsen | 1911-1915 | |||
| John H. Zundel | 1916-1918 | |||
| Job Welling | 1919-1920 | |||
| J. Clinton Lillywhite | 1921-1922 | |||
| John H. Zundel | 1923-1938 | |||
| Fred M. Sorenson | 1939-1942 | |||
| Warren Hyde | 1943-1974 | |||
| Arthur F. Redding | 1975-1978 | |||
| Robert Limb | 1979-1994 | |||
| D. Leon Jensen | 1995-2006 | |||
| Joseph "Lynn" Yeates | 2007-present |